Siemens Energy India: Numbers Mast, Par Auditor Ka Warning! Kya Naya Funda Hai?

ENERGY
Whalesbook Logo
AuthorVihaan Mehta|Published at:
Siemens Energy India: Numbers Mast, Par Auditor Ka Warning! Kya Naya Funda Hai?
Overview

Siemens Energy India ke Q1 FY26 results aa gaye hain aur company ne YoY growth mein toh kamaal kar diya hai! Revenue **26%** badhkar **₹1,910.9 Cr** ho gaya aur Profit After Tax (PAT) bhi **35%** se zyada chadh gaya **₹312.9 Cr** tak. Lekin, ek badi chaukane wali baat hai – auditor ne numbers par sawaal utha diya hai, bol rahe hain ki jo comparison figures hain woh audited nahi hain!

YoY toh mast, par QoQ mein kya hua?

Dekho, Siemens Energy India ne Q1 FY26 mein jo numbers dikhaye hain, woh year-on-year (YoY) basis par toh zabardast lag rahe hain. Revenue 26.0% badhkar ₹1,910.9 Crore ho gaya Q1 FY25 ke ₹1,516.9 Crore ke mukable. Aur PAT mein bhi 34.9% ka jump aaya, jo ki ₹312.9 Crore pahunch gaya, pichhle saal yahin ₹231.7 Crore tha. Earnings Per Share (EPS) bhi ₹8.79 tak gaya.

Lekin, agar pichhle quarter (QoQ) se compare karein, toh figures thode neeche aaye hain. Revenue 27.8% kam hokar ₹1,910.9 Crore pe aa gaya (jo pichhle quarter mein ₹2,645.7 Crore tha), aur PAT bhi 13.0% girkar ₹312.9 Crore pe aa gaya (pichhle quarter mein ₹359.6 Crore tha). Haalat ki baat karein toh, PAT margin YoY basis par thoda behtar hokar 16.37% ho gaya hai pichhle saal ke 15.27% se.

Auditor Ka Warning: Yeh Sabse Badi Chinta Hai!

Sabse bada red flag jo investors ko dekhna chahiye, woh hai auditor (Price Waterhouse Chartered Accountants LLP) ki report mein likha 'Emphasis of Matter'. Auditor ne clearly kaha hai ki pichle saal ke jo comparison figures hain, woh audited nahi hain. Iska matlab hai ki jo YoY growth dikhaya ja raha hai, woh unaudited data par based hai, jiski reliability par sawal uthta hai. MATLAB, jo 26% aur 35% ka growth dikh raha hai, woh pakka nahi hai!

Naye Plans Aur Order Book Ka Kya?

Achhi khabar yeh hai ki company ek naye power transformer factory ke liye ₹2,060 Crore invest karne wali hai, jo future ke liye kaafi bada plan hai. Aur company ka order backlog bhi mast badha hai, 37.6% YoY jump ke saath ₹17,599 Crore ho gaya hai. Naye orders bhi ₹3,343 Crore ke aaye hain, jo 3.7% zyada hai pichhle saal se.

Risk Factor Kya Hai?

Investors ke liye sabse bada risk yahi auditor ka note hai jo YoY comparison data ko unaudited bata raha hai. Uske alawa, QoQ numbers mein jo girawat aayi hai, usko bhi nazarandaaz nahi kar sakte. Aur yeh ₹2,060 Crore wali factory ka execution risk bhi hai. Toh bhai, numbers toh acche lag rahe hain, par auditor ke warning ko bilkul bhi halka mat lena!

Disclaimer:This content is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, financial, or trading advice, nor a recommendation to buy or sell any securities. Readers should consult a SEBI-registered advisor before making investment decisions, as markets involve risk and past performance does not guarantee future results. The publisher and authors accept no liability for any losses. Some content may be AI-generated and may contain errors; accuracy and completeness are not guaranteed. Views expressed do not reflect the publication’s editorial stance.