Whalesbook
Labour Codes Notification Sparks Gratuity Confusion
The recent notification by the Centre declaring four new Labour Codes effective from November 21, 2025, has introduced significant confusion among both employees and employers, particularly concerning changes to gratuity eligibility. A key point of contention is whether gratuity is now payable after only one year of service instead of the traditional five years, and if this change is effective immediately.
The Core Issue
Further confusion has been fueled by a government statement in Parliament indicating that it is "pursuing with the States/UTs for smooth implementation of the Codes." This has led many to believe that certain benefits, including gratuity, might still be pending. However, a closer examination of the law and expert opinions reveals a more nuanced situation.
The Centre has officially clarified that the four Labour Codes have come into force on November 21, 2025. While the Labour Ministry is indeed working with states and Union Territories for smooth operational implementation, this does not mean the core provisions are on hold. The substantive legal entitlements are active.
Gratuity Change Under New Code
The Code on Social Security, 2020, has expanded gratuity rules in a significant way. Fixed-term employees are now entitled to gratuity on a pro-rata basis, irrespective of whether they have completed five years of continuous service. This is a critical distinction from the traditional five-year eligibility condition that remains in place for regular, non-fixed-term employees.
Immediate Applicability of Gratuity Entitlement
Labour law experts emphasize that the legal entitlement itself is already in force. When the Codes "come into force," the substantive provisions become immediate law. The right of fixed-term employees to receive gratuity on a pro-rata basis is considered part of this substantive law and does not depend on state rules for its existence. States can only prescribe procedural details for implementation, not deny the entitlement itself.
In essence, the concept of gratuity for fixed-term employees becoming applicable even before five years is now legally established from November 21, 2025. This change aims to bring parity for workers hired on fixed contracts.
What Still Depends on States/UTs
While the entitlement exists, the practical aspects of implementation will hinge on rules notified by individual States and Union Territories. These rules will likely cover procedural details such as the manner and timelines for payment, required forms and documentation, and inspection and dispute resolution procedures. Provisions requiring specific rules for full practical operation may not be immediately enforceable in all their details, but this does not postpone the underlying legal obligation.
Regular Employees' Gratuity Rule Unchanged
Experts strongly clarify that the widely circulated claim suggesting all employees will receive gratuity after just one year is inaccurate. The five-year continuous service rule remains the standard for permanent employees. The one-year, or shorter tenure, gratuity benefit is exclusively for fixed-term employees and is calculated on a pro-rata basis.
Why Employers Must Not Ignore the Change
Ignoring the gratuity provision for fixed-term employees could expose employers to significant retrospective liabilities. Since the Code on Social Security is already in force, employers are expected to immediately factor in gratuity costs for their fixed-term workforce. HR and payroll systems should be reviewed and updated to ensure compliance. Delaying action based on the assumption that specific rules are still awaited could lead to considerable financial repercussions later.
What is Clearly in Force
From November 21, 2025, core definitions under all four Codes are active. This includes a uniform wage definition with a 50% wage rule, expanded social security coverage (EPF, ESI, maternity, gratuity), gratuity for fixed-term employees on a pro-rata basis, a higher retrenchment threshold under the Industrial Relations Code, and paid leave and safety provisions under the OSH Code.
What is Operationally Evolving
Certain aspects are still in the process of operationalization and depend on state-specific notifications. These include registration and licensing processes, inspection mechanisms, forms, returns, and compliance formats, as well as state-specific thresholds and procedures.
Understanding "Smooth Implementation"
When the Centre mentions "smooth implementation," experts interpret this as the legal framework being live, with states expected to quickly notify their respective rules to ensure seamless compliance. Until then, existing procedures continue as interim measures where they do not conflict with the new Codes.
Bottom Line for Employees and Employers
The Labour Codes are indeed in force from November 21, 2025. Gratuity for fixed-term employees is legally applicable from this date. The five-year gratuity rule for regular employees remains unchanged. State rules will govern the processing of gratuity, not its fundamental eligibility for fixed-term staff. Employers are advised against a passive approach, while fixed-term employees stand to gain from this expansion of social security benefits.
Impact
This change has a moderate impact on Indian businesses by altering employment cost calculations for a segment of the workforce. It mandates proactive HR and payroll adjustments for companies employing fixed-term staff, potentially leading to increased operational complexity and costs. Investor sentiment could be affected by the anticipation of these changes. Impact rating: 7/10.
Difficult Terms Explained
- Labour Codes: A set of four laws passed by the Indian Parliament to simplify, amalgamate, and update India's labour laws.
- Gratuity: A lump sum payment made by an employer to an employee as a token of gratitude for services rendered, typically after completing a minimum period of service.
- Fixed-term employees: Individuals hired for a specific duration or project, with their employment ending on a predetermined date.
- Pro-rata basis: Calculated in proportion to the time served. For gratuity, it means receiving a fraction of the total amount based on the tenure.
- Regular employees: Permanent employees of an organization without a fixed tenure.
- Substantive provisions: The fundamental rights and obligations established by a law.
- Procedural details: The rules and steps required for the practical application and enforcement of a law.