Whalesbook
Antitrust Probe Names Steel Giants Over Price Fixing
India's competition watchdog, the Competition Commission of India (CCI), has determined that major steel producers Tata Steel, JSW Steel, and state-owned Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL), alongside 25 other entities, engaged in anti-competitive practices. A confidential order reveals these companies allegedly colluded on steel selling prices, a violation of Indian antitrust law. This finding places the firms and numerous executives at risk of significant financial penalties.
The CCI's investigation, initiated in 2021 following a criminal case filed by builders, initially focused on nine companies. It has since expanded to encompass 31 companies, industry groups, and dozens of senior executives. Among those identified as liable for price collusion spanning periods between 2015 and 2023 are JSW's Sajjan Jindal and Tata Steel's T.V. Narendran. The preliminary findings state the parties' conduct contravened antitrust laws, with specific individuals also held accountable.
Market Dominance and Potential Penalties
India, the world's second-largest crude steel producer, sees robust demand driven by infrastructure development. JSW Steel commands approximately 17.5% of the domestic market, followed by Tata Steel at 13.3%, and SAIL at 10%. The CCI possesses the authority to levy penalties of up to three times a company's profit or 10% of its annual turnover for each year of infringement. Executives found liable can also face personal fines.
The investigation gained traction after builders alleged steel companies artificially restricted supply and hiked prices by as much as 55% in six months. Evidence cited in internal CCI documents includes WhatsApp messages exchanged between regional industry groups, suggesting explicit price fixing and production cuts. The CCI has requested detailed financial statements from the accused companies to assess potential penalties.
Next Steps in the Investigation
The current findings are a crucial phase; they are not final judgments. Top CCI officials will review these determinations. Companies and executives implicated will have several months to present any objections or counterarguments. Following this review process, the CCI will issue its public final order, concluding this high-profile antitrust case.