Whalesbook
SEBI Considers Major ETF Pricing Overhaul
The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) is exploring a substantial change to how Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) are priced and traded. Sources indicate SEBI might permit the use of the previous trading day's indicative net asset value (iNAV) to set the base price for ETF price bands. This move aims to significantly reduce the current lag in ETF pricing.
The Core Issue: A Two-Day Lag
Currently, Exchange Traded Funds in India operate with a pricing mechanism that lags by two trading days. The base price used for determining the permissible price band is derived from the Net Asset Value (NAV) from two days prior (T-2). This contrasts with individual stocks and indices, which use the previous day's closing price (T-1). This one-day difference can create a disconnect between the ETF's traded price on the exchange and the actual value of its underlying assets.
Proposed Solution: Embracing Real-Time Data
SEBI's proposed change would align ETF pricing more closely with market realities. By allowing the use of the latest available indicative net asset value (iNAV) from the previous trading day (T-1), the base price would be much more current. The iNAV is calculated using the most recent traded prices of the ETF's underlying securities throughout the trading day, making it a more timely indicator.
Challenges and Industry Concerns
While the shift to T-1 data seems logical, exchanges have raised practical concerns. The Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI), the industry body, has previously noted that iNAV might differ from the official day-end NAV. Furthermore, the official NAV data is published with a delay by AMFI, complicating the real-time availability required for exchanges to download it promptly for trading sessions.
Manual adjustments for corporate actions occurring on T-1 also introduce risks of errors or missed updates when relying on older T-2 NAV data. Using T-1 iNAV is expected to simplify these operations and reduce such risks.
Rethinking Price Band Structure
Beyond the base price calculation, SEBI is also evaluating changes to the price band structure itself. The current uniform ±20% price band for all ETFs might be replaced. Proposals include an initial ±10% band, which could then be expanded up to ±20% during the trading session if movements in the underlying index warrant it. Such adjustments would likely be subject to a cooling-off period.
Market Impact and Future Outlook
This regulatory evolution is anticipated to enhance the efficiency of the Indian ETF market. A reduced pricing lag should lead to tighter tracking of underlying assets and potentially narrower bid-ask spreads, benefiting investors. It could also make ETFs more attractive as investment vehicles. SEBI has yet to issue a formal discussion paper or draft for public feedback on these proposed changes.
Impact Rating: 7/10
Difficult Terms Explained
- Exchange Traded Fund (ETF): A type of investment fund that holds assets like stocks, bonds, or commodities, and trades on stock exchanges like individual stocks.
- Indicative Net Asset Value (iNAV): An estimated real-time Net Asset Value for an ETF calculated during market hours using current prices of its underlying securities.
- Net Asset Value (NAV): The per-share market value of an investment fund. It is calculated by taking the total value of the fund's assets, subtracting its liabilities, and dividing by the number of outstanding shares.
- T-1: Refers to the previous trading day.
- T-2: Refers to two trading days prior to the current trading day.
- AMFI: Association of Mutual Funds in India, an industry body that represents mutual funds in India.